By Michael Beaver, Real Estate Agent, Baird & Warner Evanston. Published November 5, 2025. Updated November 16, 2026.
Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, 2026. If you'd rather shop local than fight the big-box crowds, Chicago's North Shore and North Side have long-running butchers, bakeries and specialty shops worth the stop. Here's where to go, and when to order.
Key Takeaways
- Order early, especially fresh turkeys, pies and prepared sides. Many shops sell out the week of Thanksgiving.
- Mid-week pickups usually mean shorter lines than the weekend before the holiday.
- Expect traffic on Waukegan Road in Glenview and Lincoln Avenue in the city during the peak days.
- Hours and holiday menus change every year, so check each shop's site or call before you go.
Turkeys And Meat
Harrison's Poultry Farm, Glenview
Waukegan Road, Glenview
Harrison's has sold poultry in Glenview since 1893 and is a Thanksgiving stop for many North Shore shoppers. It sells fresh turkeys, along with eggs, sausage and other prepared items.
Tip: Order your turkey ahead, and pick up mid-week if you can. The line on the weekend before Thanksgiving can stretch out the door. Check Harrison's site for this year's ordering details.
Paulina Market, Chicago
3501 N. Lincoln Ave., Chicago
Paulina Market has been a butcher shop on Lincoln Avenue since 1949. It sells fresh turkeys, roasts and house-made sausages, and its smoked turkey is an option if you'd rather skip the oven.
Tip: Pick up some of the sausages for an easy breakfast while you cook.
Bakeries And Sweets
Bennison's Bakery, Evanston
1000 Davis St., Evanston
Bennison's has been baking in Evanston since 1938. Stop in for bread, pastries and holiday pies, or pre-order for the best selection.
Tip: Grab extra bread for leftover turkey sandwiches.
Misericordia Hearts & Flour Bakery and Café, Chicago
6130 N. Ravenswood Ave., Chicago
Misericordia's bakery and café bakes cookies, cakes and other treats, and purchases support Misericordia. Its baked goods and gift boxes make good hostess gifts.
Tip: Shop early in the week. Popular items go fast as the holiday gets close. Check Misericordia's site for hours.
Round Out Your Table
The Bottle Shop, Wilmette
1148 Central Ave., Wilmette
This downtown Wilmette shop carries more than 400 wines plus craft beer, cheeses and snacks. Ask the staff for pairing ideas for turkey and dessert.
Foodstuffs, North Shore
Foodstuffs is a long-running North Shore gourmet shop and caterer with prepared sides, sauces and catering trays. Check its site for current locations and holiday menus.
Tip: Order holiday sides early. They often sell out before Thanksgiving week.
The Flower Shop in Glencoe
693 Vernon Ave., Glencoe
This boutique floral studio and gift shop in downtown Glencoe can make a seasonal centerpiece for your table.
Tip: Order your arrangement a few days early and keep it somewhere cool. It'll stay fresh through the weekend.
Bringing It All Home
Shopping local for the holiday is a good excuse to get to know the businesses in your town, whether that's the butcher who remembers your order or the bakery down the block. Order early, go mid-week and enjoy the holiday.
Thinking about a move to the North Shore or the North Side in the new year? Our area guides cover each town's shops, parks and transit, starting with Evanston, Wilmette and Glenview. Or book a consultation and call or text 773.368.1969.
Shop details checked November 16, 2026. Hours, menus and ordering deadlines change, so confirm with each shop.